Recovering from knee replacement surgery can be a challenging journey, but the right tools can make a significant difference.
Two common options for knee replacement recovery are exercise programs and traditional ice machines. In this guide, an expert physical therapist compares these methods to help you understand their unique benefits and drawbacks, enabling you to make informed decisions about your knee replacement recovery.
Skip Ahead:
- Key Benefits of Ice Machines
- Ice Machine Cons for Knee Replacement Recovery
- What Works Best for Knee Replacement Recovery?
- Weighing the Alternatives
- Luxury vs. Necessity: Making the Right Choice
- The Final Verdict
- Expert Tip from a Physical Therapist
- Schedule a Free 30 Minute Call with Physical Therapist & Co-Creator of GoKnee, Shehla Rooney
Ice Machines: A Classic Cold Therapy Solution
Ice machines, also known as cold therapy machines, are a more traditional method used to reduce pain and swelling after knee replacement surgery. These devices circulate cold water through a pad that wraps around the knee, providing consistent and adjustable cooling.
Ice Machines: Key Benefits
- Affordability: Ice machines vary in cost from $50 all the way up to over $500. Many are covered by insurance plans, which makes them an accessible option for many patients.
- Simplicity: These devices are fairly easy to use, with minimal setup required, making them convenient for immediate post-surgery recovery.
- Effective Pain Relief: Consistent cold therapy effectively reduces pain and controls inflammation, both of which are important after knee replacement surgery.
Ice Machines: The Icy Drawbacks
- Limited Functionality: Ice machines provide cooling and can feel ‘good’, but they do not directly improve knee mobility or flexibility, which is a crucial component of knee replacement recovery.
- Self-Limiting: Because Ice Machines can be worn for extended periods of time and can provide much needed pain relief, you may spend too much time during the day in a recumbent position with the Ice Machine on, instead of doing the necessary exercises required to actually improve knee motion and strength.
- Bulky and Inconvenient: While effective, Ice machines can be bulky and require frequent refilling of ice or water, which can be inconvenient or difficult to do, especially if you don’t have someone to assist you.
Ice Machine Alternatives: What Works Best?
GoKnee is a home recovery program designed by physical therapists (PT) to aid in knee replacement recovery. It aims to improve knee range of motion (ROM), strengthen the knee, and reduce swelling and pain. The program includes a lightweight knee device and step-by-step instructional exercise videos that can be followed at home.
What Makes GoKnee Different?
- Comprehensive: GoKnee’s exercise program helps with all facets of knee replacement recovery, including knee motion, stiffness, pain, swelling, and the strength of the muscles around the knee, all of which are crucial for optimal recovery.
- Convenience: Designed for home use, GoKnee allows you to perform advanced exercises every day, instead of just 2-3 times per week in the PT clinic. Being able to perform advanced exercises 7 days per week results in a faster recovery.
- Control Your Pain: GoKnee’s patented knee device mimics the hands of a PT, allowing you to perform advanced exercises at home. However, the difference is that you are in control of how hard you push yourself, resulting in less fear and anxiety than when the PT places their hands on your post-surgical knee.
GoKnee: Weighing the Challenges
- Cost: GoKnee is more expensive than traditional ice machines and is not covered by insurance, which could make it less accessible for some patients.
- Effort Required: The exercise program requires you to actively participate and do the exercises to reap the benefits, whereas with an Ice Machine, you can passively lay there.
- New Product: Given that GoKnee is a newer product, there is a high likelihood that your physical therapist or surgeon has not heard about it. Many individuals want an endorsement from their health care provider before using something for their knee recovery.
Luxury vs. Necessity: Making the Right Choice
When it comes to knee replacement recovery, considering the luxury versus necessity aspect of these devices is essential.
GoKnee, with its knee device and customized exercises, might seem like a luxury due to its higher cost and advanced functionality. However, its comprehensive approach to recovery—combining pain reduction, edema management, stretching, and strengthening—can make it a necessity for those seeking a faster, smoother recovery from this challenging surgery.
When speaking in terms of cost, it is important to mention that using GoKnee as part of your knee replacement recovery can result in a reduction in the number of PT sessions you may need, which offers savings in co-pay costs, travel costs to/from appointments, and your loved ones taking less time off work.
In addition, GoKnee has prevented the need for ‘Manipulation Under Anesthesia’ (MUA) which is another procedure that can cost you money, not to mention will extend your recovery time and keep you from returning to work or leisure activities.
The Final Verdict
Ultimately, the choice between GoKnee and traditional Ice Machines depends on individual patient needs, preferences, and resources.
GoKnee does offer a more integrated and more effective rehabilitation experience, but at a higher cost and with increased effort on your part.
In contrast, Ice Machines provide a cost-effective solution for pain and swelling, but do not directly impact the physical or functional aspects of recovery.
You should always consult with your healthcare providers to determine the best option for your specific situation, considering factors such as the extent of your surgery, your recovery goals, and your financial and logistical constraints.
Expert Tip From a Physical Therapist:
My expert tip is that you definitely need to control the pain and swelling after knee replacement surgery. This can be accomplished with an Ice Machine, but also with a bag of ice cubes or frozen peas and some pillows.
If you need to choose between GoKnee and an ice machine, I recommend opting for the one that aids in bending and straightening your knee. While reducing pain and swelling is important, it’s the improvement in knee mobility that will help you walk without a limp, get up from a low chair, and return to activities like playing Pickleball.
So, if you’re considering your options, GoKnee’s advanced home exercise program is well worth the investment so that you can walk without a limp, get up from a low chair and get back on the Pickleball court.
If you’re interested in learning more about Ice Machines versus ice packs, check out this insightful article comparing Ice Machines to ice cubes:
Get Personalized Recovery Advice: Book a 30-Minute Consultation with GoKnee’s Creator
Shehla Rooney, one of the co-creators of GoKnee and an expert physical therapist, offers free 30-minute consultations for those interested in exploring her innovative knee recovery program.
This consultation is a fantastic opportunity to ask questions, get tailored advice for your knee replacement journey, and understand how GoKnee can specifically benefit your recovery journey. Call (833) 446-5633 or email RECOVER@THEGOKNEE.COM to schedule your consultation.
Join Our YouTube Community
Subscribe to GoKnee on YouTube to connect with fellow knee replacement surgery patients. Share your journey, ask questions, and gain confidence in your recovery.